NEW YORK- The Zionist Organization of America (ZOA) is deeply disappointed by the Reform movement’s resolution unfairly criticizing Israel.
ZOA National President Morton A. Klein said:
By blaming Israel for the ‘troubling humanitarian conditions’ of the Palestinian Arabs and criticizing Congress for its recent pro-Israel resolutions, the Reform movement is harming Israel’s reputation and undermining support for Israel on Capitol Hill and in the public arena.
The Reform movement took issue with recent pro-Israel resolutions passed by Congress for not emphasizing the need for a return to the negotiating table and not focusing on the troubling humanitarian conditions of the Palestinians. This sort of criticism undermines Israel’s standing in Congress, by making Congressmembers more reluctant in the future to pass pro-Israel resolutions.
Klein noted that Rabbi Eric Yoffie, president of the Union for Reform Judaism, has compared the Palestinian Arabs to neo-Nazis. Unilateral withdrawal means creation of a Palestinian Arab state — that is, a neo-Nazi state, the ZOA president said. Nobody should be encouraging the creation of a sovereign neo-Nazi state.
The ZOA president emphasized: At a time when Israel is facing constant terrorism and international pressure, every Jewish organization has a moral obligation to find ways to help and strengthen Israel, not undercut Israel’s standing or smearing her name. With the vicious attacks on Israel from the likes of the International Court, the United Nations, Jimmy Carter, Ralph Nader, Senator Ernest Hollings, and Rep. Jim Moran, every Jewish group should be extra careful not to provide more ammunition for their attacks on Israel.
He noted that Reform movement president Eric Yoffie said the Palestinian Arab press uses ‘neo-Nazi language’ (speech to the Union of American Hebrew Congregations national board, June 1, 2001), and Martin Weiner, immediate past president of the Central Conference of American [Reform] Rabbis, who said, ‘the Palestinians really do not want peace’ (Jerusalem
Post, March 7, 2002). We agree with Rabbis Yoffie and Weiner, the ZOA president said. It makes no sense to give a sovereign state to people who do not want peace and use neo-Nazi language.
Klein disputed the Reform resolution’s call for strengthening the Palestinian Authority, noting that a regime that wages war against Israel, and uses ‘neo-Nazi’ language, should not be strengthened; it should be dismantled. He said that just as the United States did not negotiate with Saddam Hussein, the Iranian mullahs, or Adolf Hitler, there should be no negotiations with the PA. Negotiations with a terror regime such as the PA can produce nothing except to legitimize that regime’s lies and terrorism, he said.
The ZOA president noted that the Reform resolution demands that Israel pay compensation to Palestinian Arab landowners who are inconvenienced by the security fence. This is wrong; the security fence was built in response to the Palestinian Authority’s terrorist war; it is the PA that should compensate the farmers.
He also expressed concern about the Reform statements’ call for more U.S. involvement in the Arab-Israeli negotiating process. Traditionally, U.S. involvement or engagement in Mideast negotiations has meant more U.S. pressure on Israel to make one-sided concessions to the Arabs. If the Arabs sincerely wanted peace with Israel, there would be no need for U.S. involvement.