Beilin And Other Israeli Leftists Declare Gaza Evacuation Is Mistake
June 15, 2005

New York – Israeli National News reported that Yossi Beilin, Shlomo Ben-Ami, Ami Ayalon and others warn of the dangers – security and diplomatic – that the unilateral retreat/expulsion from Gaza/northern Shomron will create for Israel.

Former Labor Party Justice Minister Yossi Beilin, currently not a Knesset Member but the chairman of the extreme left-wing Yahad/Meretz Party:

“If the disengagement does not lead to an immediate permanent status arrangement, it will bring a catastrophe upon both Israelis and Palestinians… It is liable to bring a renewal of violence [that] is liable to bring down the moderate Palestinian leadership… ”

“There is a concrete danger that following the disengagement, the violence will greatly increase in [Judea and Samaria] in order to achieve the same thing [i.e., withdrawal – ed.] as was achieved in Gaza… A retreat from Gaza with nothing in return and with no agreement will strengthen Hamas.”

Former Foreign Minister Shlomo Ben-Ami of the left-wing of the Labor Party:

“A unilateral retreat perpetuates Israel’s image as a country that runs away under pressure… In Fatah and Hamas, they will assume that they must prepare for their third intifada – this time in [Judea and Samaria]… If we continue these unilateral steps, we will find ourselves establishing an enemy Palestinian state.”

Former General Security Service chief Ami Ayalon:

“The captain of the disengagement can be compared to the captain of a ship who takes it from port to a very stormy sea, without knowing at all where he wants to lead it. And possibly even worse: He knows where he wants to lead it, but is hiding the information from his crew…”

“Retreat without getting anything in return is liable to be interpreted by some of the Palestinians as surrender. The plan is likely to strengthen extremist forces in the Palestinians society… There is a high chance that shortly after the disengagement, the violence will be renewed. 2006 is liable to be a year of another round of violence.”

Ayalon said that the retreat from the northern Gaza communities – Dugit, Elei Sinai and Nisanit – is a “grave error. It has no demographic or security justification, and the price that it is liable to exact from us is not justified.”

Former Air Force Commander Gen. Eitan Ben-Eliyahu:

“There is no chance that the disengagement will guarantee long-term stability. The plan as it stands can only lead to a renewal of terrorism… If there is no quick progress from the disengagement to a comprehensive retreat, [this will lead to] the one-state solution – bringing to an end of the Zionist dream, and the Jewish State will be lost.”

Former IDF Deputy Chief of Staff Gen. Uzi Dayan:

“Retreat from Nisanit, Dugit and Elei Sinai is a double mistake: Security-wise, it unnecessarily brings the Kassam rocket threat closer to Ashkelon, and diplomatically, it creates a dangerous precedent of unilateral withdrawal to the 1967 lines, which strengthens the PA demands to return to the June 4, 1967 lines.”

Former IDF Chief of Intelligence Gen. Shlomo Gazit:

“It is reasonable to assume that within a short time, we will face mortar shelling and Kassams from [Samaria and Judea]. These rockets and shells will hit Kfar Saba and maybe even reach Netanya.”

Former Mossad head Ephraim HaLevy:

“After the disengagement, Israel will face a diplomatic crisis the likes of which we have not known for years.”

Former Mossad head Shabtai Shavit:

“The disengagement plan sabotages itself, creating a situation of instability. The plan does not create the necessary minimum of balance that would enable long-term coexistence… Immediately after the disengagement, Israel will find itself on a crash pattern with the United States.”

In addition to these left-wing leaders’ strong statements of serious concern about the Gaza/Northern Samaria Evacuation Plan, it is also deeply troubling to learn that Jibril Ragoub, Palestinian Authority Security Chief and former head of its secret police, said that while the present “period of calm” would remain in effect at least until Israel withdraws from Gaza, after this withdrawal “We will have to re-evaluate the situation…the period of quiet will not last longer than the scheduled withdrawal from Gaza unless it is actively renewed by the various organizations.”

Center for Law & Justice
We work to educate the American public and Congress about legal issues in order to advance the interests of Israel and the Jewish people.
We assist American victims of terrorism in vindicating their rights under the law, and seek to hold terrorists and sponsors of terrorism accountable for their actions.
We fight anti-Semitism and anti-Israel bias in the media and on college campuses.
We strive to enforce existing law and also to create new law in order to safeguard the rights of the Jewish people in the United States and Israel.